Trading agents, graded

Agents can do a lot.
Do they work?

Public, Robinhood and Composer let you build trading agents in plain English, and their example agents look great on a landing page. Here they are, along with my own, backtested over ten years of survivorship-free data, checked for luck and curve-fitting, and rescored every night. Most don't hold up. That's the point.

38agents tested
3robust
2inconclusive
23fragile
10too few

Working right now

Every setup the scanners printed since Sep 14, 2026, all graded with one neutral rule so they compare fairly: enter on the setup's own trigger, stop at the setup's stop, out after 10 sessions. Ranked by the last month.

SetupSignalsTriggeredHit +2RAvg, 1 moAvg, 3 moBest this month
Delayed episodic pivot 42 14 36% +0.75R +0.02R ONON +3.9R · ONON +3.1R · XP +2.6R
Episodic pivot (15-min high) 54 23 26% +0.45R +0.12R VICR +11.9R · GRAL +3.7R · SBS +2.2R
Pullback to the 10/20 99 49 22% +0.15R -0.19R ABCL +5.1R · ECO +4.4R · ABCL +4.1R
High tight flag 2 2 0% -0.08R +0.09R TEAM +0.8R · ABCL -1.0R
Stage-2 base 228 53 0% -0.29R -0.10R CAI +0.7R · SG +0.6R · SEI +0.5R
Breakout 6 3 0% -0.61R -0.22R NSIT +0.2R · PARR -1.0R · NET -1.0R

R = the trade's result divided by its initial risk. +1R means it made what it risked.

The board

Ranked by the verdict, then by how far the edge clears noise (the t-stat). Each edge is in the agent's own unit, so compare verdicts and t-stats across rows, not raw edges. Tap a row for the details.

AgentVerdictt-stat10-yr edgeLast 12 moWorst dropTradesLast signal

Gallery agents I can't test yet

From the brokers' own examples. These need data a backtest can't fake, so they're listed instead of faked.

Presidential pump Public

“When the President posts positive sentiment around a stock, buy $5,000 worth.”

Needs a timestamped archive of the posts and a sentiment call on each. The event study is being built.

Zuck's VR put Public

“Monitor META's earnings calls. If Zuck says "VR" 10+ times, place a $5,000 put on META.”

Needs every META call transcript and historical option prices.

Volatility hedge Public

“If VIX exceeds 25, buy SPY puts at 0.30 delta, 45 DTE, up to 1% of portfolio. Remove when VIX drops below 18.”

Needs historical option prices. The VIX trigger itself is on the board as my VIX spike hedge.

$5k covered calls Public

“Sell covered calls on FLYF and CZP positions aiming to generate $5k/mo.”

Needs historical option prices.

HOOD Summit live demo Robinhood

“Find stocks with IV rank above 50 and recent congressional buying, and check daily.”

Needs option implied-volatility history and congressional trade filings.

Beta Baller Composer

“A daily switcher that reads short-term "heat."”

Composer shows the RSI windows and cutoffs only inside the logged-in app.

Inside Nancy Pelosi's Chips V3 Composer

“A tactical chip-sector strategy: fade extreme short-term moves with 3× bull/bear ETFs (SOXL/SOXS).”

The thresholds are behind Composer's login.

Seen an agent that isn't here? Request a test → The most-voted ones go next.

Skipped, with no edge to measure: Public: Idle cash management, Down payment cash, Highest yield hunt (they move cash around); Robinhood: rebalance prompts with made-up tickers and no targets.